Laue
English

Crystallography in brief

A few pages to place what Laue does. They show what a crystal is and how its symmetry is described. They then show how diffraction lets us see it, and the steps that lead from an unknown sample to the positions of its atoms.

A crystal: a lattice and a motif

A crystal is an arrangement of atoms that repeats identically in the three directions of space. It is described in two parts.

In short: crystal = lattice + motif. Three vectors a, b, c generate the lattice, and the parallelepiped they span is the unit cell. Its six parameters (a, b, c, α, β, γ) and the coordinates of the atoms, as fractions of these vectors, are enough to describe the whole crystal.

There are two kinds of cells:

In the plane, the idea is the same with two vectors: a wallpaper, a tiled floor or a fabric are “two-dimensional crystals”.

A tiling of plane group p4gm
In the plane: a motif repeated by the lattice and by the symmetries of plane group p4gm.
The unit cell of rock salt and its 4-fold axes
In space: the face-centred cubic cell of rock salt, with its 4-fold axes.
The formulas

A lattice point, and any point in fractional coordinates:

r=u a+v b+w c,u,v,w∈Zx=x a+y b+z c\mathbf{r} = u\,\mathbf{a} + v\,\mathbf{b} + w\,\mathbf{c},\quad u, v, w \in \mathbb{Z} \qquad\qquad \mathbf{x} = x\,\mathbf{a} + y\,\mathbf{b} + z\,\mathbf{c}

The metric tensor GG holds the six cell parameters; it gives distances, angles and the volume:

G=(a2abcos⁡γaccos⁡βabcos⁡γb2bccos⁡αaccos⁡βbccos⁡αc2),∣Δx∣2=ΔxTG Δx,V=det⁡GG = \begin{pmatrix} a^2 & ab\cos\gamma & ac\cos\beta \\ ab\cos\gamma & b^2 & bc\cos\alpha \\ ac\cos\beta & bc\cos\alpha & c^2 \end{pmatrix},\qquad |\Delta\mathbf{x}|^2 = \Delta\mathbf{x}^{\mathsf T} G\,\Delta\mathbf{x},\qquad V = \sqrt{\det G}

Symmetry, level by level

Periodicity strongly restricts the possible symmetries. A lattice can only have rotation axes of order 1, 2, 3, 4 or 6: this is the crystallographic restriction. A regular tiling of pentagons is impossible, and so is a crystal with 5-fold symmetry. Symmetries are therefore classified by levels, each one building on the previous.

  1. The point group gathers the rotations, mirrors and inversion that leave a point fixed. It tells what the crystal looks like from afar, without seeing its atoms: the shape of its faces, the anisotropy of its properties. There are 32 of them. They are drawn in stereographic projection and divided into 7 crystal systems, from triclinic to cubic.
  2. The Bravais lattices are the 14 ways of arranging lattice points in space: primitive (P), body-centred (I), face-centred (F), one-face-centred (A, B or C), rhombohedral (R).
  3. The space group combines the two. It adds operations that have no point equivalent: screw axes (a rotation followed by a fraction of a translation, such as 21 or 42) and glide planes (a mirror followed by a half translation). There are 230 space groups, and 17 plane groups in the plane. Their Hermann–Mauguin symbol, such as Fm-3m or P2_1/c, gives the lattice type, then the symmetry elements along the principal directions.
  4. Wyckoff positions classify the points of the cell by their local symmetry. An atom placed on a symmetry element has fewer copies in the cell than an atom in a general position. The product of its multiplicity and the order of its site symmetry is constant. This is the language of structure descriptions: “Na on 4a, Cl on 4b”.
In the planeIn space
Crystal systems47
Point groups1032
Bravais lattices514
Plane groups, space groups17230

Symmetry also shows in physical properties. According to Neumann's principle, every property of a crystal has at least the symmetry of its point group. A cubic crystal is therefore optically isotropic. Piezoelectricity, on the other hand, requires the absence of a centre of symmetry.

Stereogram of point group m-3m
The stereogram of m-3m, the point group of rock salt: the 48 equivalent positions of a general direction.

In Laue, the Tiling workshop covers the 17 plane groups and the 7 frieze groups. The Crystal workshop covers the 230 space groups, with their Wyckoff positions, their symmetry elements in the cell and their stereograms.

The formulas

A symmetry operation in Seitz notation: a linear part RR and a translation t\mathbf{t} (fractional for a screw axis or a glide plane):

{R ∣ t}:x⟼R x+t\{R\,|\,\mathbf{t}\} : \mathbf{x} \longmapsto R\,\mathbf{x} + \mathbf{t}

The crystallographic restriction: in a lattice basis, RR is an integer matrix, and so is its trace. For a rotation by 2π/n2\pi/n:

tr⁡R=1+2cos⁡2πn∈Z⟹n∈{1,2,3,4,6}\operatorname{tr} R = 1 + 2\cos\frac{2\pi}{n} \in \mathbb{Z} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad n \in \{1, 2, 3, 4, 6\}

A Wyckoff position: its multiplicity mm (in the conventional cell), the order of its site symmetry ∣S∣|S|, the order of the point group ∣P∣|P| and the number of lattice points in the cell ZlatticeZ_{\text{lattice}} (1 for P, 2 for I and C, 4 for F):

m⋅∣S∣=∣P∣⋅Zlattice(rock salt, Fm3ˉm: Na on 4a, 4×48=48×4)m \cdot |S| = |P| \cdot Z_{\text{lattice}}\qquad\text{(rock salt, }Fm\bar{3}m\text{: Na on }4a,\ 4 \times 48 = 48 \times 4)

Seeing atoms: diffraction

Interatomic distances, of the order of an ångström (10−10 m), are far too small for an optical microscope. The crystal is therefore illuminated with a wave of comparable wavelength: X-rays, neutrons or electrons. Each atom scatters a little of the wave. Because the crystal is periodic, these waves add up only in certain directions, where they form sharp spots, the reflections. Max von Laue observed this in 1912; William Lawrence Bragg gave its law the following year.

Bragg peaks of the Penrose tiling, with 10-fold symmetry
A famous exception: a quasicrystal is not periodic, yet it diffracts in sharp peaks, with a 10-fold symmetry forbidden to crystals (Shechtman, 1982; Nobel Prize 2011).

In Laue, the diffraction of a tiling, a quasicrystal or a crystal is computed with every change. You see the allowed reflections, those the group extinguishes and the reason for each absence.

The formulas

The reciprocal lattice (crystallographers' convention, without 2π2\pi) and the interplanar spacing:

ai⋅aj∗=δij,Ghkl=h a∗+k b∗+l c∗,dhkl=1∣Ghkl∣(cubic: 1d2=h2+k2+l2a2)\mathbf{a}_i \cdot \mathbf{a}^*_j = \delta_{ij},\qquad \mathbf{G}_{hkl} = h\,\mathbf{a}^* + k\,\mathbf{b}^* + l\,\mathbf{c}^*,\qquad d_{hkl} = \frac{1}{|\mathbf{G}_{hkl}|}\qquad\text{(cubic: } \tfrac{1}{d^2} = \tfrac{h^2+k^2+l^2}{a^2}\text{)}

Bragg's law, and its equivalent, the Laue condition (Ewald sphere, ∣k∣=1/λ|\mathbf{k}| = 1/\lambda):

2 dhklsin⁡θ=n λ⟺k′−k=Ghkl2\,d_{hkl}\sin\theta = n\,\lambda \qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad \mathbf{k}' - \mathbf{k} = \mathbf{G}_{hkl}

The structure factor, a sum over the atoms of the cell (scattering factor fjf_j, Debye–Waller factor BjB_j), and the intensity:

Fhkl=∑jfj e−Bjsin⁡2θ/λ2 e2πi(hxj+kyj+lzj),Ihkl∝∣Fhkl∣2F_{hkl} = \sum_j f_j\, e^{-B_j \sin^2\theta/\lambda^2}\, e^{2\pi i (h x_j + k y_j + l z_j)},\qquad I_{hkl} \propto |F_{hkl}|^2

An absence: an F lattice puts an atom at x\mathbf{x} and at x+(0,12,12)\mathbf{x} + (0,\tfrac12,\tfrac12), (12,0,12)(\tfrac12,0,\tfrac12), (12,12,0)(\tfrac12,\tfrac12,0), hence

Fhkl=F′(1+eiπ(k+l)+eiπ(h+l)+eiπ(h+k))={4F′h,k,l all even or all odd0otherwiseF_{hkl} = F'\left(1 + e^{i\pi(k+l)} + e^{i\pi(h+l)} + e^{i\pi(h+k)}\right) = \begin{cases} 4F' & h, k, l \text{ all even or all odd} \\ 0 & \text{otherwise} \end{cases}

Friedel's law (without anomalous scattering): Fhˉkˉlˉ=Fhkl∗F_{\bar h\bar k\bar l} = F_{hkl}^{*}, hence Ihˉkˉlˉ=IhklI_{\bar h\bar k\bar l} = I_{hkl}.

Probes and methods

Three probes complement each other:

The sample then dictates the method:

The powder pattern of rock salt, its Debye–Scherrer film and the table of its lines
Rock salt as a powder: the indexed lines, those the F lattice extinguishes, and the Debye–Scherrer film.

Reading a Laue pattern. Each spot comes from a family of planes that has taken the Bragg wavelength from the white beam. The planes act as a mirror: their normal is the bisector of the angle between the beam and the ray going from the crystal to the spot. From the position of the spot on the film and the distance of the film, one therefore gets the direction of the normal, then its indices (h k l) by projecting it on the axes of the cell. The wavelength of each spot remains unknown: the pattern gives the orientation of the crystal and its Laue class, not its spacings. In Laue, the Laue pattern follows the view of the Crystal workshop, and pointing at a spot gives its indices.

Three Laue patterns: rock salt along [001] in transmission, quartz along c, rock salt in back-reflection
Rock salt along [001] (symmetry 4mm), quartz along c (3m), then rock salt in back-reflection.
The formulas

The wavelength of a neutron of velocity vv, and of an electron accelerated through a voltage UU (with the relativistic correction):

λn=hmnv,λe=h2meeU(1+eU2mec2)(λe≈2.5 pm at 200 kV)\lambda_n = \frac{h}{m_n v},\qquad \lambda_e = \frac{h}{\sqrt{2 m_e e U\left(1 + \dfrac{eU}{2 m_e c^2}\right)}}\qquad(\lambda_e \approx 2.5\ \text{pm at } 200\ \text{kV})

The Scherrer formula: the size τ\tau of the crystallites, from the full width at half maximum β\beta of a line (in radians, instrumental broadening removed; K≈0.9K \approx 0.9):

τ=K λβcos⁡θ\tau = \frac{K\,\lambda}{\beta\cos\theta}

From measurement to structure

From an unknown sample to the list of atomic positions, the procedure comes down to four steps.

  1. Identify. The powder pattern is compared with a database of known phases. These are structure databases such as the free Crystallography Open Database, or pattern databases such as the ICDD Powder Diffraction File. Most often the substance is already known and the analysis stops there.
  2. Index. Otherwise, one looks for the cell that assigns indices (h k l) to every line. For a cubic cell, it is enough to see that the values of 1/d² are in the ratios of integers h² + k² + l². The absences then give the compatible space groups.
  3. Solve. The measurement gives the intensity of the reflections, |F|², but not their phase. Without phases, the electron density cannot be reconstructed: this is the phase problem. There are several ways around it:
    • the Patterson function, which does without phases and shows the vectors between atoms;
    • direct methods, which guess the phases from statistical relations (Nobel Prize 1985);
    • charge flipping, which alternates between real space and reciprocal space.
  4. Refine and validate. The model is fitted to the data by least squares: positions, thermal motion and, for a powder, the whole profile of the pattern (Rietveld method). Agreement factors such as R and χ² tell whether the model is good.

In Laue, the Crystal workshop computes the powder pattern of a structure, with or without the real atoms. It reads a real measurement and refines it (cell, zero shift, line profile, background). It indexes an unknown measurement and proposes the compatible groups. The Fourier synthesis of tilings also shows the phase problem: with the true phases, the motif comes back; with random phases, it disappears.

The formulas

The electron density is the Fourier transform of the structure factors, each of which has a modulus and a phase φhkl\varphi_{hkl}; the measurement gives only the modulus:

ρ(x)=1V∑hkl∣Fhkl∣ eiφhkl e−2πi(hx+ky+lz)\rho(\mathbf{x}) = \frac{1}{V}\sum_{hkl} |F_{hkl}|\, e^{i\varphi_{hkl}}\, e^{-2\pi i (hx+ky+lz)}

The Patterson function does without phases; its peaks lie at the vectors between atoms:

P(u)=1V∑hkl∣Fhkl∣2cos⁡2π(hu+kv+lw)P(\mathbf{u}) = \frac{1}{V}\sum_{hkl} |F_{hkl}|^2 \cos 2\pi(hu + kv + lw)

Rietveld refinement minimises the weighted difference between the measured pattern yiy_i and the calculated pattern yc,iy_{c,i}, point by point; the result is judged by RwpR_{wp} and χ2\chi^2 (NN points, PP parameters):

S=∑iwi (yi−yc,i)2,wi=1σi2,Rwp=S∑iwiyi2,χ2=SN−PS = \sum_i w_i\,(y_i - y_{c,i})^2,\quad w_i = \frac{1}{\sigma_i^2},\qquad R_{wp} = \sqrt{\frac{S}{\sum_i w_i y_i^2}},\qquad \chi^2 = \frac{S}{N - P}

Further reading

For practice, the guide describes each workshop, and the examples open in Laue with one click.